The key to mastering a turnaround is escaping the "circle
of doom," James M. Kilts, '74, told 1,200 alumni and
friends at the 49th annual Management Conference in May. Having
engineered the turnarounds of several high-profile companies,
including Kraft and Nabisco, Kilts has a track record for building
successful brand portfolios.
Now chairman and CEO of The Gillette Company, Kilts said companies
enter the circle of doom when they "set unrealistic high-growth
targets and objectives which are impossible to meet" and
"throw money at the problem, which causes overhead to build,
increased prices, and a cut in the marketing budget." He
said companies can avoid this downward spiral by following four
recommendations:
Evaluate your company with integrity
"Hold a mirror to your company and view it with total honesty,"
Kilts advised. One of the reasons Nabisco was losing ground in
the late 1990s was because it "made promises to Wall Street
which were never kept," said Kilts. As president and CEO
of Nabisco in 1998, Kilts made it a goal "to restore integrity
to Nabisco's projections." Instead of promising higher profits
than he could deliver, Kilts made sure he delivered what he promised.
While the consequence was an initial 30 percent setback in Nabisco's
stock price, Kilts said it was expected because "integrity
has a price."
Put "fire in the belly" of your team
Instead of exchanging memos and e-mails, Kilts said a leader of
a turnaround must act as "head cheerleader" and persuade
his or her team through personal meetings that "things must
and can change." More importantly, the leader must communicate
an "understandable process of change."
Have a bias toward action
Leaders of turnarounds can "never have all the information
they need" or a "prolonged quiet time in which to make
decisions." They cannot postpone important decisions and
must act upon the information they have at the time. Companies
must stop "looking for a free lunch by expecting their brands
to do all the work." Previously, Nabisco only accepted what
the market gave for such brands as Oreo and Cheese Nips. After
aggressive advertising, however, Oreo saw a 12 percent increase
and Cheese Nips a 40 percent increase.
Understand your consumer
Integrity, enthusiasm, and action must be brought together with
a clear understanding of the consumer. "Consumers can be
tricky because they are fragmented, fickle, and frustrated,"
Kilts said. Pieces of information aren't enough; you must put
that information in context.
If companies keep in mind that "brands are the company
itself and not just a part of the production," then engineering
a successful turnaround remains possible, Kilts said.--T.T.